Jurors reveal holdout blocked acquittal in Lindsay Clancy mistrial
–
Neutral summary
Three jurors from Lindsay Clancy's murder trial said a lone male holdout admitted to having reasonable doubt but refused to vote not guilty, causing the mistrial declared on September 4. Patrick Clancy's attorney threatened legal action against conspiracy theorists, saying their misinformation has led to threats against his client's 'reputation, livelihood, and life'. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington said Clancy remains 'suicidal' and will seek to have the jury sequestered in a retrial, while prosecutors have not yet decided whether to retry her.
How it was framed
Outlets: 16. Countries: 4. Facts in the shared core: 5.
Publication timeline
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Patrick Clancy's lawyer threatens conspiracy theorists with legal action. Patrick Clancy, Lindsay Clancy's ex-husband, issued a scathing statement to conspiracy theorists who have been claiming he was involved in the de…
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy’s ex-husband Patrick rips ‘real-life threats’ he’s facing over hateful influencers’ ‘misinformation’. His wife was charged with killing their three children inside the family’s Duxbury, Mass. home in Janu…
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Patrick Clancy's lawyer threatens legal action against conspiracy theorists. Patrick Clancy's lawyer threatened legal action against those who claim he had a role in his children's death. The statement came after a Mass…
-
·
ABC News (outlet profile)
Patrick Clancy's attorney calls for end to 'defamation campaign' against him. Clancy testified in the trial of his ex-wife, Lindsay Clancy.
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer reveals what could happen next after her murder case ended in a mistrial. A Massachusetts judge declared a mistrial in Lindsay Clancy's grueling six-week long trial after the jury said they were…
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy copy cat backlash – when crocodile’s attack | The Low Down. The latest headlines are anything but ordinary, from the latest developments in the Lindsay Clancy case to disturbing new revelations surroundin…
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Patrick Clancy's lawyer warns "there will be consequences" for conspiracy theorists. Lindsay Clancy's ex-husband, Patrick, is responding after conspiracy theories claimed he was involved in his children's deaths. In a s…
-
·
CBC News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy's ex-husband threatens legal action over 'relentless' conspiracy theories. Patrick Clancy was ruled out as a suspect in the 2023 deaths of his children, Cora, 5; Dawson, 3; and eight-month-old Callan. His…
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy jury was ready to find her not guilty of murder — until one man refused to agree, jurors reveal: ‘I was so excited’. The jury foreperson in Lindsay Clancy’s high-stakes triple murder trial detailed just h…
-
·
Fox News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy juror admitted 'reasonable doubt' but still refused insanity verdict, foreperson says. Three Lindsay Clancy jurors say a lone holdout admitted having reasonable doubt but still refused to deliver a not gu…
-
·
Daily Mail (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy jurors revealed: Three women break cover to share details of their explosive arguments with male holdout who wouldn't acquit. According to the trio, they argued so much with the man that the alternate jur…
-
·
The Independent (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy’s ex-husband threatens legal action over conspiracy theorists. Patrick Clancy’s attorney said the conspiracy theories have resulted in threats to his client’s ‘reputation, livelihood, and life’
-
·
NBC News (outlet profile)
Three jurors in Lindsay Clancy murder trial speak out in exclusive new interview. Three jurors from the Lindsay Clancy murder trial, which ended in a mistrial, have come forward to discuss the deliberations. The jury’s…
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy juror speaks after mistrial: "There was so much doubt". A woman who served as a juror in Lindsay Clancy's high-profile Massachusetts murder trial provided a look at deliberations, saying there was too muc…
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy's ex-husband blasts conspiracy theories as new hearing date set. Lindsay Clancy's ex-husband, Patrick Clancy, blasted claims on Tuesday that he is behind the killings of his three children. CBS News Bosto…
-
·
GB News (outlet profile)
Three jurors in Lindsay Clancy trial reveal why case shockingly collapsed. Three female jurors who were involved in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial have revealed why the case shockingly collapsed . Speaking out publicly…
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
‘Harsh’ Lindsay Clancy prosecutors helped prove she was a good mom who ‘snapped,’ jurors say. The prosecution in the Lindsay Clancy triple-murder trial were "harsh" and lacked "compassion," three jurors from the 12-pers…
-
·
The Independent (outlet profile)
Holdout in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn't acquit, juror says. A jury foreperson says the lone holdout juror in Lindsay Clancy trial said he had reasonable doubt but still wouldn’t a…
-
·
Daily Mail (outlet profile)
Clancy jurors reveal the evidence that convinced them mom was not guilty of murder before lone holdout forced mistrial. Three women who served as jurors in the Lindsay Clancy trial have opened up about their decision to…
-
·
Newsweek (outlet profile)
Biggest Bombshells From Lindsay Clancy Jurors After Child Murder Mistrial. Three jurors from Lindsay Clancy's murder trial have broken their silence days after the case ended in a mistrial.
-
·
The New York Times (outlet profile)
Three Jurors in Clancy Trial Describe Frustration With Holdout. The three jurors, who voted to acquit Lindsay Clancy of murder, described the tense deliberations in an interview with a Boston TV station.
-
·
Mondo (outlet profile)
Kako je propalo suđenje majci koja je ubila troje dece: Porota htela da oslobodi Klensi, jedan čovek minirao sve
-
·
The Independent (outlet profile)
Patrick Clancy takes aim at ‘minor celebrities’ fueling conspiracy theories about his children’s deaths
-
·
Telegraf (outlet profile)
Porotnici umalo proglasili nevinom Lindzi Klensi, optuženu za ubistvo dece: Evo zašto je suđenje poništeno. Porotnici na suđenju Lindzi Klensi prvi put su javno govorili o tajnom većanju i onome što je dovelo do njihovo…
-
·
Newsweek (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy Trial: What We Know About Mysterious Holdout Juror. A lone male juror prevented Lindsay Clancy from being acquitted in her murder trial, three jurors said in an interview.
-
·
NBC News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy Jurors Speak Out on Mistrial and the Lone Holdout. For the first time, members of the jury in the closely-watched Lindsay Clancy trial are speaking out on the tense dayslong deliberations over Clancy’s fa…
-
·
Pink (outlet profile)
Poništena presuda majci u SAD: Zbog njenog postupka usledio veliki preokret na suđenju. Članovi porote na suđenju Lindzi Klansi prvi put su javno otkrili šta se dešavalo tokom većanja i zašto je taj slučaj, koji je priv…
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy jurors speak on holdout, share details from deliberations. Jurors from the Lindsay Clancy murder trial are speaking out after it was declared a mistrial last week. Shanelle Kaul reports.
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy trial juror speaks out about mistrial. The high-profile murder trial of Lindsay Clancy ended in a mistrial after jurors could not come to a unanimous decision on the verdict. Now, one juror is speaking ab…
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy's attorney says he's going to ask for case to be thrown out. Lindsay Clancy's defense attorney Kevin Reddington joins "CBS Mornings" to discuss the high-profile case and what he expects to happen next.
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy's attorney says he will ask for case to be thrown out. Kevin Reddington, the lawyer for Lindsay Clancy, said he will present a motion to dismiss on Sept. 29 at a previously scheduled status hearing.
-
·
Daily Mail (outlet profile)
Now FOURTH Lindsay Clancy juror makes extraordinary admission after deliberations swayed her vote: 'I thought she was guilty... maybe I still do'. The juror, who remained anonymous, said she had not followed the high-pr…
-
·
The Independent (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy jurors describe the comment that changed everything after they thought they had an acquittal. The holdout juror was described as ‘very arrogant’ by some of the other jury members
-
·
Fox News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy juror who initially leaned guilty reveals 'strong personalities' in deliberation room: report. Lindsay Clancy trial jurors reveal the lone holdout wasn't the only one who initially favored a guilty v…
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy juror defends lone holdout, makes surprising admission about others on the panel. A female juror in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial has defended the lone male holdout – admitting that he “was not the only…
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy's lawyer says he hopes Trump intervenes to help "resolve this tragic case". Lindsay Clancy's lawyer Kevin Reddington told "CBS Mornings" that he plans to file a motion for her case to be thrown out after…
-
·
The Mirror (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy jurors fuming at 'arrogant' holdout as deliberations spiralled into arguments and name-calling. A juror on the Lindsay Clancy trial claimed the holdout, that saw the case turn to a mistrial, 'admitted he…
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
What happens to Lindsay Clancy if her case gets thrown out?. Kevin Reddington, Lindsay Clancy's defense attorney, sat down with "CBS Mornings" on Wednesday, where he said he plans to ask for the case to be thrown out. C…
-
·
NBC News (outlet profile)
Kevin Reddington: Lindsay Clancy wants her babies. In his sit-down interview with NBC News’ Laura Jarrett, Kevin Reddington, the defense attorney for Lindsay Clancy, says the woman who's living amongst us is the person…
-
·
ABC News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy trial jurors speak out after mistrial. Jurors in the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy spoke out in interviews this week, after the judge declared a mistrial following days of jury deadlock.
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy lives in sad reality after mistrial and ‘constantly’ repeats harrowing plea, Kevin Reddington says. Kevin Reddington shared the harrowing plea clancy is "constantly" saying -- after her high-profile tripl…
-
·
NBC News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy’s attorney details her mental state after mistrial. Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mother accused of strangling her three young children to death in 2023, is “not very good” and remains “suicidal” afte…
-
·
The Hill (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy attorney will ask for jury to be sequestered in new trial. Prosecutors have yet to make a decision on retrying Lindsay Clancy after a mistrial was declared in the case.
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy’s complex case: Letters to the Editor — Sept. 10, 2026. NY Post readers discuss a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy case as jurors could not agree on her insanity defense.
-
·
CBS News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy Mistrial: Reddington Weighs In | Case by Case | "48 Hours" Podcast. In the wake of the mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy murder case, CBS News correspondent Shanelle Kaul and WBZ-TV reporter and anchor Krist…
-
·
Fox News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy juror who backed the defense also publicly cheered Karen Read's acquittal. A juror in the Lindsay Clancy mistrial previously voiced support for Karen Read online.
-
·
ABC News (outlet profile)
Clancy juror says holdout didn't show 'single piece of evidence' explaining vote. Clancy's five-week trial ended in a mistrial on Sept. 4, after a jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict.
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
Lone Lindsay Clancy holdout juror did not provide ‘single piece of evidence’ to support his vote: fellow juror. Lindsay Clancy juror Nick Dargie says the lone holdout failed to provide any evidence for his vote, forcing…
-
·
Daily Mail (outlet profile)
Male Lindsay Clancy juror breaks silence to describe moment he pressed lone holdout and how it led to mistrial. Nick Dargie, 25, one of the three men who served on the jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial, has revealed how…
-
·
Fox News (outlet profile)
Lindsay Clancy's lawyer reveals post-mistrial strategy as retrial looms. Lindsay Clancy's attorney Kevin Reddington reveals his strategy after the mistrial, urging prosecutors to pursue treatment instead of prison…
-
·
New York Post (outlet profile)
Lone Lindsay Clancy juror mimicked the horrific stranglings of killer mom’s three kids: ‘I was shocked’. “I was so shocked. We’re not here to play detective – it’s not a game of Clue. This is serious,” Nick Dargie said.
Factual core
- Lindsay Clancy's murder trial ended in a mistrial.
- Three jurors from Lindsay Clancy's murder trial spoke publicly after the mistrial.
- Patrick Clancy threatened legal action over conspiracy theories about him.
- The jury in the Clancy trial failed to reach a unanimous verdict.
- The jurors' public statements explained why the case resulted in a mistrial.